Aneurin is a former New York City star, who gives up his rising fame to move back home. Hopper is the local historian and eccentric, who runs the town bookstore. Together, they run the local theatre group's annual reenactment of The Legend of sleepy Hollow. This year, they have something special planned, an interactive show that will move the audience around the village. However, during the last dress rehearsal, the two men find that their headless corpse on the Headless Horseman bridge prop has been switched for a real person. With the police looking into the theatre troupe for the murder, Aneurin and Hopper decide their best bet is to investigate on their own. Together with Penelope Winters, the village witch, the two men must hunt down the murderer before becoming his next victims. Surrounded by witchcraft, mystery, and misdirection, the two men also find themselves falling in love.