A fat black cat resides on a farm of Farmer Bill's like so many other animals. He is not just skeptical, but also a little flattering in his appearance. This leads him to approach a few other animals on the farm, intriguing them with his attempts to persuade them to agree with him on what he says. However, when the other animals listen to him, each of them has their own opinion of their appearance until Farmer Bill steps in. Which animal's opinion will Farmer Bill agree with after all?