New York City. 1977. Santino De Luca, and his wife, Maria, and their three kids, live in a beautiful condominium called Carnegie Hill Place. Shortly after Santino announces his intention to run in the next Strata Council meeting, he's found dead by their daughter, Lucia, in their bathtub, filled with red paint. NYPD investigators deemed the incident a suicide and closed the case. But Santino's brothers, Angelo and Sal, are convinced that poor Santino was murdered. They hire Lee to uncover the truth.