Angels, an old song, and a love letter. The perfect mix for a Christmas miracle! Reformed cat burglar Tony Russo is looking forward to spending this first Christmas together with the love of his life, Abigail. He's hoping for jingle bells, goodwill towards all, and lots of kisses under the mistletoe. Then, he and Abigail find a Christmas angel tree topper in the church's donation box with a secret of its own, and their lives suddenly become intertwined with others as they search for clues. Their days before Christmas are taken up with solving a mystery, helping those in their community, and saving a wayward kitten. When a lonely, homeless man shows up in their lives, Tony and Abigail realize that things aren't always as they seem, and that God may be using the stories of others to bring about the couple's own Christmas miracle.